|
- Who sold this car to you?
Panel beater in Roebuck
- Don't take this vehicle into the desert!
Arthur at Broome Toyota
- This vehicle should not have been rented to you!
Baz Car Mechanics Halls Creek
- Buckle up mate! Your engine is hanging on by the gearbox
mount!
Sean at L & M Motors Darwin
- This chassis has been seriously twisted sometime!
Shell Autocare Alice Springs
Car Connection is a rental company based in Glenluce outside
Castlemaine (2 hours outside Melbourne). Their business
idea is to buy old Ford Falcons and Toyota Landcruisers
and rent them to people for a fixed rate for up to 6 months.
You pay $4.500 for a Landcruiser 60-series for 6 months.
If you use it for the whole time, the daily rate will theoretically
be less than $30 a day. Too good to be true? Definitely!!!
You can also rent camping equipment for $250
from them, which includes an Esky, a gas stove, cutlery
and cooking pans, tent and mats, storage box, stools and
a table and tools and spares for the car. I found that the
camping equipment worked basically fine, with a few minor
remarks. Like the stools were a pain to sit on, so I bought
a proper chair after a while.
The first car I was in, proved to be below
expectations, and had some very serious problems. I ended
up paying for some of these repairs, which all in all plus
service amounted to over $1.500. The problem with these
serious faults are in my mind not the money (shit happens)
but the constant feeling of insecurity while driving on
dirt roads in the outback. The second serious problem is
that I had to spend about 20% of the time during the first
three months to wait for repairs. This time could have been
better spent camping out in the bush.
I could have put up with spending the extra
money, even the delays and the feelings of insecurity on
remote dirt roads, if Car Connection, especially Kurt Weidner
had had a more positive attitude to his customers. I let
you, the reader be the judge of if Car Connection's services
should be trusted at all.
|
Incidents / Service / Repairs
|
Car Connections Comments
|
Delay
|
What I Paid
|
What Car Connection Paid
|
|
1 April: Picked up the car which had the following
problems at hand over (discovered during the trip):
No fuel in tank when leaving Car Connection. Managed
to fill 83 litre in an 80 litre tank at the first
service station. Never managed to squeeze in that
much again. Only the drivers door could be opened
with a key. If the backdoor was locked, then you would
have to crawl from the front seat all over the gear
to open the door from the inside. Steering very
hard, see below. Only one front light worked satisfactory.
Lights to number plates did not work. Bent and worn
out air filter Front diff had not been serviced for
ages. Chassis seriously twisted Under-dimensioned
brake discs
|
|
|
|
|
|
4 April: On the third attempt to start the
car, the starting motor went dead.
|
Kurt Weidner agreed to pay this repair, included
in the 5.000 km warranty
|
5 days
|
$505
|
$505
|
|
17 April: After sliding into a tree on the
Gunbarrel Highway, the car got a dint in the front
right guard, smashed the top of the snorkel. Probably
a combination of too high speed and the faulty front
diff and under-dimensioned brake discs, see below.
A window fell out at the same time, see below.
While examining the vehicle, we discovered that the
front diff leaked seriously. A nipple to a breather
hose was obviously the wrong kind and was clogged
up. Previous hard driving of the vehicle plus the
nipple problem are the probable causes of the leaking
diff. Nipple fastened temporarily with sealing mass.
|
|
|
|
|
|
18 April: 5.000 km service in Meekathara,
according to contract. Recommended to change air filter
which was old and bent and useless.
|
Wrote a formal complaint to Car Connection about
the state of the car, which they never have replied
to or commented.
|
|
$60
|
|
|
20 April: Got new filter for snorkel in Newman
at mine workshop. Cheapest repair on the trip.
|
|
|
$12
|
|
|
23 April: Got new window at panel beater in
Roeburne. The panel beater told me that the window
had been hanging on by the isolation to the frame
and that it might be a great risk that other windows
might fall out as well.
|
Car Connection has denied all responsibility for
this faulty installation.
|
|
$80
|
|
|
24 April: Consulted Toyota in Broome. Their
representative Arthur, told me that the vehicle shouldn't
be driven into the desert, due to the leaking front
diff.
|
Phoned Car Connection. Kurt Weidner stated that (1)
nothing was wrong with the car, (2) outback mechanics
were just fishing for money after the rain season,
(3) the 4WD shouldn't be used anyway, especially not
in the Kimberley (4) I could suit myself since I had
taken the car over the Gunbarrel "anything can happen
there".
Note: Car Connection had been informed about my route
prior to the journey. Their representative Hartmut
Meier even commented that it was a nice route. Nothing
was mentioned about that the Gunbarrel was a forbidden
road.
|
|
|
|
|
27 April: Checked in the vehicle with BP service
station in Derby, as a measurement before taking on
the Kimberley. Couldn't get a time for repairs until
the 29 April. Pretty depressing to hang around in
Derby.
|
|
2 days delay
|
|
|
|
29 April: Leaking pinion seal at the front
diff changed by BP. Hubs tightened so that they shouldn't
leak so much.
|
|
|
$60
|
|
|
14 May: Checked in the vehicle with BP service
station Kununurra for contractual 10.000 km service.
Got time 2 days later. Bought new air filter instead
of the bent one and changed it.
|
|
|
$25
|
|
|
16 May: BP Service Station, Kununurra made
thorough check of vehicle. Changed oil, oil and fuel
filter, attached various loose parts. They found the
following problems:
Rear shock absorber twisted, due to years of
abuse. Serious diff oil leak from both front and rear
diff. Serious leak from right front hub. Nipple to
breather hose faulty dimension, thus aggravating problems
with leaking right front hub. Uni joint to propeller
shaft cracked, needed replacing.
BP advised me not to use the 4WD. My plan was to drive
down to Alice Springs and make the rest of the repairs
there.
|
BP Service Station was recommended by Car Connection's
representative Hartmut Meier.
|
2 days.
|
$200
|
|
|
21 May: Checked in the vehicle for service
in Hall's Creek, before going down the Tanami Track.
Got time the next day.
|
|
|
|
|
|
22 May: BAZ Car Mechanics in Hall's Creek
refused to service the car, due to the serious state
of the leaking front hub. "This vehicle should not
have been rented to you!" The front wheel could now
be rocked like a loose front teeth. Tried to drive
down the well graded Tanami Track to Alice Springs
in 2WD. Had to turn back to Hall's Creek due to a
heavy rainstorm.
|
|
2 days.
|
|
|
|
23 May: Phoned Car Connection from Kununurra
and described the state of the front hub, the blown
shock absorber, the leaking front and rear diff and
the cracked uni joint at the propeller shaft.
|
Hartmut Meier agreed to pay for the repairs. We agreed
that the car should be repaired in Darwin, a small
detour of 1.000 km. Hartmut Meier recommended L&M
Motors in Darwin.
|
|
|
|
|
26 May: Booked time with L&M Motors 2
days later. A 2 day job. Sean at L&M Motors forbid
me to leave the city when he saw the condition of
the vehicle. Had to skip to go to Litchfield National
Park and had to stay in Darwin instead.
|
|
|
|
|
|
28 May: Left vehicle for service.
|
Hartmut Meier had talked to Kurt Weidner, who had
decided that they after all would not pay for all
of the repairs. I was to pay for new shock absorbers,
and half of the welding and repair of the uni joint.
|
|
|
|
|
29 May: Got vehicle back. Sean at L&M
Motors informed me that the car had the following
problems: Under-dimensioned brake discs, clearly the
wrong kind for this model of vehicle. Probably together
with faulty 4WD contributed to tree accident. Engine
mounts cracked. Engine hanging on by the gear box.
Sean's comment: Buckle up mate! Rear springs worn
out. Steering damper gone, which made the steering
very hard. Metal in the rear diff oil. The rear bearings
about to grind down.
|
|
8 days. The days in Darwin were especially boring
and costly.
|
$227
|
|
|
11 June: Problem with cracked engine mounts
prevented me from driving on dirt road. Had problems
with the engine rushing unexpectantly. The purpose
of renting a 4WD was mostly lost since I could only
drive on bitumen roads. Booked a time for service
in Alice Springs with Shell Auto Service (recommended
by Hartmut Meier).
|
Phoned Car Connection. Hartmut Meier denied any form
of responsibility for the state of the vehicle. When
asked what would happen if the rear bearings grinded
down in the desert, Hartmut Meier replied:
"- Then you can disconnect the propeller shaft and
drive back with the front diff. I do it all the time."
Needless to say, this is not how you intend to spend
your holiday. Needless to say, driving a Toyota Landcruiser
with only the front diff, can cause serious damage
to the front transmission. If Car Connection really
does this with their cars, then it might explain why
the front hub was so badly damaged.
|
|
|
|
|
13 June: Left vehicle at Shell Auto Service
for contractual 5.000 km service and to fix the problems
discovered by L&M Motors. Engine couldn't be fitted
back in. They needed a few more days to fix the problem.
Engine mounts had been changed by someone to a faulty
version for this kind of engine. Chassis appeared
to be twisted, according to Shell Auto Service. The
twisting could not have been caused by bumping into
a small tree, according to them. Shell Auto Service
provided the following explanations for the twisted
chassis: A severe front crash. Something very heavy
had been dragged with the vehicle. This second guess
proved to be correct.
|
|
|
|
|
|
16 June: For every day, waiting for the car
to be repaired, I got more and more depressed. The
journey seemed to consist more of waiting for expensive
repairs, than experiences in the bush. I decided that
I wanted to use two more of my contractual 2 months.
Felt like going to the Barrier Reef and dive.
Got car back from service. Got told that this was
the best they could do, the vehicle was not road worthy
in the opinion of Shell Auto Service. Record breaking
expenses for the repairs.
Tried to buy new front guard from Dave's Auto Wreckers
(north in Alice). Dave refused to sell me a front
guard when he heard the story of how Car Connection
had sent me out without diesel in the tank.
|
Phoned Car Connection. Hartmut Meier informed me
that (1) they would not pay a cent for the repairs,
(2) the vehicle had been sold so I couldn't use it
for another two months.
|
|
$578
|
|
|
19 June:
|
Phoned Car Connection who offered a replacement to
the vehicle. Unsuccessfully tried to convince Hartmut
Meier that it would be criminal to sell the vehicle
to someone. Hartmut Meier informed me that the customer
had driven the vehicle before and knew what he was
getting. I further had to drive down to Victoria to
pick up the new car. No exchange could be done in
between. Talk about a detour!
|
|
|
|
|
23 June: Dave at the Auto Wreckers in Alice
was on business trips. Managed to talk his employees
into selling me a front guard though Dave had forbidden
them.
|
|
|
|
|
|
24 June: New front guard fitted. What a beauty
of a vehicle.
|
|
2 days.
|
$350
|
|
|
3 July: Drove from Melbourne to Glenluce,
Castlemaine to pick up replace vehicle. Drove old
vehicle together with Hartmut Meier to a panel beater.
Agreed on price with panel beater for a paint job.
Hartmut Meier got receipt for job for tax deduction
(I couldn't do much with that receipt anyway).
Checked the new vehicle. Leaks in the rear diff.
|
Hartmut Meier claimed that "All Landcruisers leak
in the rear diff." This statement is obviously false.
|
14 days. It took about an extra week to drive down
to Victoria, and then another to drive up to Port
Douglas, while it would have taken me about 3-4 days
from Alice to Port Douglas.
|
$400
|
|
|
10 July: Left new vehicle for a road worthiness
check in Longreach. I didn't exactly trust Car Connection
at this point. Front shock absorbers about to break.
Tested the 4WD on a sandy dirt road for an hour. Front
hubs started to leak, but not as seriously as the
old vehicle though.
|
|
|
$30
|
|
|
21 July: Diesel hand pump fell off. Made temporarily
repair in Musgrave. Lacked the right tools due to
that Car Connection had provided me with the wrong
size of spanners.
|
|
|
$20
|
|
|
24 July: Contractual 5.000 km service in Normanton.
No serious problems showed up, except for leaking
gear box.
|
|
|
|
|
|
28 July: Run out of diesel just outside Mt
Isa. Refuelled with my extra diesel, but couldn't
pump out the air without the hand pump. Got towed
into Mt. Isa. Had new hand pump fitted. Expensive
but quick job.
|
|
|
$100
|
|
|
22 August: Returned vehicle just due for 10.000
km service. Left the vehicle in Castlemaine at Car
Connection's usual mechanics. The old vehicle was
still standing there! It had not been repaired or
sold yet!
|
Car Connection's representative Ashley told me the
following story. "- I might be the source of the problems
you had with the first car. See, I dragged a one ton
trailer off road on the Canning Stock Route constantly
in 4WD when I used the vehicle as a back up vehicle
on one of our motorcycle tours. I had the big six
wheel army truck as well. Once that got stuck in the
sand, so I dragged it out of a bog with the Landcruiser.
We're sorry about that and I promise you that you
will get a super treatment the next time you come."
Except, there will not be another time I use Car Connection's
services.
|
|
|
|
The conclusion of my experiences
with the first vehicle, is that it was a car that had no
place in the outback at all. The second vehicle was in a
better shape. I would not have had as many, if any of the
problems and delays I experienced if I had been in the second
vehicle. Kurt Weidner constantly blamed the problems either
on me, or tried to make condescending remarks about Australian
outback car mechanics competence. Kurt Weidner has written
a letter to me, the 6 May 1998, concerning this page. Here
again he states his condescending remarks about Australian
car mechanics as an explanation of the problems and delays
I had with the first car.
"What most likely made you feel very uncomfortable
were the vage comments of some outback mechanics."
Here again in his letter, Kurt Weidner implies
that the problems really didn't exist, and that the state
of the first car couldn't have lead to any serious hazards.
The front wheel that was about to fall off, the seriously
leaking front hub, the window that was hanging on by the
isolation, the cracked engine mounts, the broken uni joints,
the broken shock absorbers, the broken steering damper,
the temporarily repaired breather hose, the cracked mounting
on the rear diff, the worn out springs, the doors that couldn't
be locked, just to name a few problems, were all too real
to me. It's hard to follow Kurt Weidner's line of reasoning.
Could all this events have been a result of
my imagination and exaggerations of Australian outback car
mechanics?
I must reply a firm and resounding No! to that
question.
Just as the answer to the question, should
you rent a vehicle from Car Connection only has one answer
and that is:
No!
|